A Chip Muffin Isn't a Muffin: Why Real Photography Still Matters
Last week, the BBC reported on Just Eat's experiment with AI-generated food photography, and the results were rather extraordinary. A chip muffin became an actual muffin with chips poking out of it, while a bacon-and-egg soda bread dish was transformed into breakfast ingredients floating in a glass of cola. The company subsequently apologised for the inaccurate images and paused the rollout while the technology is improved.

The examples are undeniably funny, but behind the amusement lies a serious question about how businesses present themselves. If a photograph is supposed to help somebody decide what to buy, shouldn't it actually represent what they're going to receive?
A picture makes a promise
Food photography does more than decorate a menu. It helps customers understand what they're ordering, what to expect and whether something looks worth buying. When that picture is inaccurate, the customer is effectively making a decision based on something that doesn't exist.

The most obvious AI mistakes are easy to laugh at, but the more convincing ones could be just as problematic. An artificially perfect meal, an exaggerated portion or ingredients that aren't actually included might look fantastic on screen, but what happens when the real thing arrives?
This extends well beyond restaurants. Manufacturers need accurate product imagery, venues need photographs that reflect their actual surroundings, and service businesses benefit from showing the real people behind their work. Investing in professional business photography gives customers something tangible to recognise and trust, rather than simply another attractive picture.
Knowing your audience is part of the job
Most people familiar with northern takeaway menus understand that a chip muffin isn't a cake. The AI didn't, and that misunderstanding highlights something important about creative work: context matters.
A professional photographer, designer or marketing team brings more to a project than the ability to create something visually appealing. They understand the intended audience, question unclear instructions, recognise when something doesn't look right and consider whether the finished material accurately represents the business.
That knowledge becomes particularly important when businesses are communicating regional differences, specialist products or services that cannot easily be represented by generic imagery. Whether producing a promotional campaign or developing professional graphic design and sales collateral, a convincing image is not necessarily a correct one, and knowing the difference is part of the job.
AI has its place. So does the real world.
None of this means artificial intelligence has no place in marketing. It can be useful for exploring concepts, experimenting with layouts and producing illustrative material where creativity matters more than literal accuracy. Used properly, it can become another tool in a professional creative workflow.
But there's an important difference between creating an illustration and presenting something as a photograph of a real product or experience. When customers need to know what they're actually getting, genuine photography and informed human review are difficult to replace.
At Betrsaga, we believe creative work should communicate something meaningful about the business behind it. Sometimes that means using new technology, and sometimes it means investing in a photographer, designer or marketing professional who understands exactly what needs to be shown.
Because the best marketing doesn't just look convincing. It gives people a reason to believe what they're seeing.
Questions businesses often ask
Should businesses avoid AI-generated images altogether?
Not necessarily. AI-generated imagery can be useful for conceptual illustrations, visual experimentation and creative campaigns. However, when an image is intended to represent a real product, place or experience, accuracy should take priority over convenience.
Why is professional photography still important for businesses?
Professional photography helps businesses show their actual products, people and working environments. Alongside good design, it creates distinctive, trustworthy marketing material that reflects the business rather than relying on generic or artificially generated representations.
Can businesses combine AI with professional design?
Absolutely. AI can support brainstorming, concept development and parts of the production process. A professional designer or creative team can then provide the judgement, brand understanding and quality control needed to ensure the finished material is accurate, appropriate and effective.


